Paper 1 · Comprehension
Passage
According to a study published recently in the journal Nature Climate Change, while black carbon has a large effect on snow darkening and the resultant melting of snow, dust particles transported from as far as Saudi Arabia that get deposited in the Western Himalayan Region (WHR) have a large role to play in the melting of snow, particularly at higher elevations. Dust transported as elevated aerosol layers gets deposited at 1 to 5 km elevations, while black carbon emission is mostly a surface phenomenon and influences the melting of snow from the surface to about 3 km elevation. Based on remote sensing data of the spatial distribution of dust aerosol concentration over the Indian subcontinent, and on dust-induced snow albedo reduction over the Himalayas during 2011 to 2016 and simulations, it has been inferred that the relative impacts of dust and black carbon vary with the surface elevation of the snow pack. This is in addition to snow-melt caused by warming due to climate change. Earlier studies have shown that the magnitude of snow mass decrease is about 1 mm per year at 1 km elevation, about 5 mm per year at 4.5 km elevation, and about 3 mm per year at 6 km elevation. Though black carbon has a larger snow albedo darkening effect than dust, due to a larger mass absorption efficiency, the study found that the radiative effects of dust deposited on snow are comparable to black carbon in the WHR at higher elevations. This is mainly because the deposition of dust by mass is 100 to 1000 times more than black carbon. As the elevation increases, the influence of dust becomes greater than black carbon, and this coincides with the maximum intensity of snow melt reduction seen at 3 to 5 km elevation. Between these two, black carbon mainly contributes to snow melt at lower elevations, while dust is the major contributor at higher elevations. Westerlies transport dust particles as elevated aerosol layers at maximum intensities mostly during the pre-monsoon period, and this gets deposited at higher elevations in the WHR. Due to global warming, snow cover at lower elevations in the Himalayas will occur less frequently or totally disappear compared with snow cover at higher elevations. The annual contribution of dust to snow melt will therefore likely increase in future, as the black carbon effect at lower elevations weakens with the dwindling snow pack.
The passage clearly brings out the finding that
ABlack carbon causes global warming
BDust causes global warming
CDust modifies the radiative properties of snow cover to exactly the same extent as black carbon everywhere
DBlack carbon and dust are competing agents in the melting of snow packs ✓ Correct
Correct answer: (D) Black carbon and dust are competing agents in the melting of snow packs — The finding is that black carbon and dust are competing agents in the melting of snow packs, so that is the answer.
Explanation
★The finding is that black carbon and dust are competing agents in the melting of snow packs, so that is the answer.
★The passage compares the roles of black carbon and dust in melting Himalayan snow throughout.
★It says black carbon mainly drives snow melt at lower elevations.
★It says dust is the major contributor to snow melt at higher elevations.
★So the two act as rival agents whose relative weight shifts with the elevation.
★The passage does not say either simply causes global warming, nor that dust matches black carbon everywhere, so the finding is that they are competing agents in the melting of snow packs.
Want more like this? Create a free account to practise a full test, track your progress, and get spaced-repetition review.
Shared by Mcqkart · via Mcqkart.in
