Consider the example of anumana given below: (a) The mountain is fiery. (b) Because it has smoke. (c) Wherever there is smoke, there is fire. Which one of the following expresses Vyapti (the relation of invariable concomitance)?
AThe relation of invariable concomitance between mountain and fire
BThe relation of invariable concomitance between mountain and smoke
CThe relation of invariable concomitance between fire and smoke ✓ Correct
DThe relation of invariable concomitance between perceiver and smoke
Correct answer: (C) The relation of invariable concomitance between fire and smoke
Explanation
Vyapti here is the invariable concomitance between smoke and fire.
Step (b) supplies smoke as the mark on the mountain.
Step (c) states that wherever there is smoke there is fire.
This universal tie holds between the mark, smoke, and the inferred, fire.
It is this relation of smoke to fire that licenses the inference, not smoke to mountain.
The invariable concomitance of the middle with the major is vyapti.
Want more like this? Create a free account to practise a full test, track your progress, and get spaced-repetition review.
Practise on Mcqkart →🎓 Book an expert →